asking wrong question
instead of how much time left
how much of your mind
I digress to start, but I believe I am correct when I say that Prince is again recognized by that name today and not by the ‘Artist Formerly Known as Prince (TAFKAP), or simply the Artist.
I ask that as today, Prince joins my Pantheon of the Giants of Word Use, Big Bill, Mr. Sandburg, Hemingway, EB White; Et al) whose content I steal and work into a haiku.
The line I quote:
Instead of asking him how much of your time is left
Ask him how much of your mind, *
Popped into my brain while reading the Guest Essay Could A.I. Be Conscious? It’s Definitely Possible, Toni Sims, a researcher at the Center for Mind, Ethics and Policy at New York University.
Ms. Sims writes:
Of course, you can never know for sure whether a machine is conscious, just as you can never know for sure whether anyone is conscious other than yourself. As philosophers have long recognized, the only conscious experience each of us can directly observe is our own. Instead, we have to evaluate the consciousness of other beings indirectly, through an examination of the available evidence. We infer that our fellow humans are conscious because of our shared biological makeup, as well as how they behave and talk — including, notably, that they say they are conscious.
So while we will never be completely certain whether A.I. systems are conscious, we should still collect and weigh the evidence, because getting the question wrong carries serious risks. If we assume A.I. is not conscious when it actually is, we could end up abusing and neglecting vulnerable beings in enormous numbers — as I believe we do with animals. If we decide that A.I. is conscious when it really isn’t, we could end up misplacing our moral concern and abdicating control over what are, or should be, powerful tools that we can use to advance human and animal well-being.
Reading this piece, my objections boiled over like baking soda in vinegar as I sought the right words to say, ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
I felt like I was losing my mind.
Maybe that’s what brought the words of Prince to mind.
And I focused on Instead of asking …
Instead of asking … Could A.I. be concious?
Ask .. Could A.I. have a soul?
And I am here to tell that the answer to that question is … NO!
Quoting Yeats, could A.I. write a poem that makes the soul clap its hands and sing, and louder sing?
Sure, I guess.
Could A.I. READ a poem that makes its soul clap its hands and sing, and louder sing?
NO!
A.I. and machines in general DO NOT HAVE A SOUL.
Years ago a toy came out called a gigapet which was tiny machine that needed attention in the way of pressing a button or two every couple of hours to ‘stay alive’.
My kids all had them and kept them going for most of a day.
They were MACHINES.
AI is a machine.
At the end of the day, we can turn them, we should turn them OFF.
I make it a point to tell co-workers that computers can be like dogs and sense fear and play on that with some users so it is important, from time to time, to unplug your computer and wave the end of the cord in front of your monitor.
I do worry that this conversation will go down the road of machines being conscious and then, somehow, having rights, having standing in court.
But always, ALWAYS, keep in mind, computers, AI, any machine, has no soul.
To the line, So while we will never be completely certain whether A.I. systems are conscious, we should still collect and weigh the evidence. I say I am certain.
I say we can uplug these machines without concern.
Unplug with impunity.
Unplug fearlessly.
Unplug with prejudice.
And for those days when the elevator tries to get you down ..
GO CRAZY!
Oh the thoughts that come with an extra hour of sleep due to the time change.

- Complete quote:
So when you call up that shrink in Beverly Hills
You know the one, Dr. Everything’ll-Be-Alright
Instead of asking him how much of your time is left
Ask him how much of your mind, baby
‘Cause in this life
Things are much harder than in the after world
In this life
You’re on your own
And if de-elevator tries to bring you down
Go crazy



