clumsiness of world
behavior compared to
powers of planning
The New York Times article, In Ohio, Toxic Wastewater Is Bubbling Up Out of the Ground by Quinn Glabicki, climate reporter for The New York Times, is a good, if scary read.
Mr. Glabicki writes:
The fracking boom has transformed the United States into the world’s largest producer of natural gas. But fracking also produces huge volumes of salty wastewater laden with heavy metals, radioactive materials and cancer-causing benzene, as well as hazardous chemical additives from the fracking process.
Ohio became a destination for wastewater because decades ago, long before fracking, it received permission from the federal government to regulate its own injection wells, which were then just a small part of the oil and gas industry. As a result, today it’s easier to drill injection wells in Ohio than in states like Pennsylvania where there’s federal oversight.
The industry says injection wells are tightly regulated, and that thousands of feet of rock and shale safely contain the wastewater. Injection wells, “when properly sited, constructed, operated, and regulated, do not pose a significant threat to drinking water,” said Rob Brundrett, president of the Ohio Oil and Gas Association.
At a Republican Party executive meeting last August, Ohio State Senator Brian Chavez, who stepped down as DeepRock’s chief executive after taking elected office in 2023, downplayed the threat posed by injection wells, describing the brine as “ancient seawater,” according to an ethics complaint filed against him with the state’s legislative ethics committee. Mr. Chavez, who chairs the senate energy committee, also compared the radioactivity levels of the waste to that of a banana, according to the complaint, which was filed by residents of Washington County over his relationship with DeepRock.
A spokesman for Ohio Senate Republicans called the ethics complaint meritless.
In a statement, Laura Goins, an attorney for DeepRock, said, “We respect the concerns that have been raised by members of the community and believe those concerns deserve to be addressed through a science-based regulatory process.” She said “DeepRock remains committed to protecting public health, drinking water resources, and the environment.”
Got to love the language and words here.
… when properly sited, constructed, operated, and regulated, do not pose a significant threat to drinking water,
… remains committed to protecting public health, drinking water resources, and the environment.
Yeah ………… sure.
Remember any one of us who grew up in the United States between 1923 and 1975 will show the effects of leaded gas in our bones.
Centuries from now, if the world still exists, archeologists will be able to date skeletons by measuring the lead in our bones.
So all this Fracking that leads to large amounts of natural gas and some oil has an unseen price tag.
Who would have guessed that pumping wastewater from fracking underground could have unforeseen negative impace.
Of course had they been predicted, they would no longer have been unforeseen.
And isn’t the word, unforeseen, a great word?
According to the word history website, etymonline: “not foreknown,” late 14c., from un- (1) “not” + past participle of foresee. Similar formation in Middle Dutch onvoresien, Dutch onvoorzien, Middle High German unvorsen. A verb unforesee “fail to anticipate” is attested in 17c.“
I like that dutch version.
Onvoresien.
Fail to anticipate.
Unforeseen points to it wasn’t our fault, who knew?
While, Fail to anticipate …
Seems like someone should have known better.
I am reading the book Random Harvest by James Hilton (Boston: Little, Brown And Company, 1941).
Neither here nor there but if you are casting about for something to read this summer I recommend downloading the epub version from FadedPage (click here) for free.
Mr. Hilton also wrote Lost Horizons of Shangri-La fame and Good bye Mr. Chips.
Random Harvest starts with the epigram:
“According to a British Official Report, bombs fell at Random.” — GERMAN OFFICIAL REPORT
Anyway, reading along I came to this passage that is the source for today’s haiku.
Mr. Hilton writes about the hero of Random Harvest that:
He was increasingly interested in the background of knowledge and theory behind the lives of men, and the astounding clumsiness of world behavior compared with the powers of the planning mind. To use Werneth’s favorite word, he found the paradox teasing.
There is a lot packed into those two lines, especially:
the astounding clumsiness of world behavior compared with the powers of the planning mind.
To use Werneth’s favorite word, he found the paradox teasing.
That Mr. Clausewitz writes that no plan lasts 5 minutes after the battle starts.
Still, when you read about all the planing, meetings, proposals, public hearings and investigations when anything from a sidewalk crossing to a super highway to a bridge to some corporate marketing plan, the clumsiness of world behavior compared with the powers of the planning mind is truly astounding.
The paradox is assuredly teasing.
It seems even God himself looking down on the world today might murmur … something went wrong here.





